Both have free money calculators, and they answer different questions. NerdWallet's calculators project forward from growth rates you set. Ctrl Alt Decide replays what really happened at a real place and date.
| NerdWallet | Ctrl Alt Decide | |
|---|---|---|
| What it answers | What might happen: it projects forward from rates you enter or accept. | How a choice turned out: it replays what really happened at a real place and date. |
| Where the numbers come from | Growth rates set by you or by NerdWallet's defaults, such as "Home appreciation (yearly)", "Rent increase (yearly)" and "Annual rate of return". | Published records for your place and month: HM Land Registry, ONS, Zillow, Freddie Mac, Bank of England and more. You can type over any figure. |
| Rent or buy | Yes, projected forward from the rates above. US only. | Yes, for over 600 UK and US places, back to 2015. |
| Overpay the mortgage or invest | An early payoff calculator that finds the extra payment needed. No invest-instead comparison. | Yes: overpaying against investing, back to 2000. |
| Lease or buy a car | A lease payment calculator. It doesn't compare leasing with buying. | Yes: leasing, a car loan or paying cash, compared. |
| Savings or investing | Compound interest and savings calculators, with a return rate you estimate. | Cash savings against the stock market, with real savings rates and returns back to 2000. |
| Moving city | A cost of living comparison for US cities, using today's prices. | Pay, rents and house prices in two places, replayed since 2015. |
| Pay against inflation | An inflation calculator that converts a dollar amount between dates with the US consumer price index. No pay comparison. US only. | Yes: your pay then and now against prices and actual average pay, UK and US, back to 2000. |
| Stock markets by country | An investment calculator that grows money at a rate of return you type in. No real past returns and no other countries. | Yes: two countries' real share prices side by side, in pounds or dollars, back to 2000. |
| Packed lunch or buying | None found. Its savings and budget calculators use amounts and rates you enter. | Yes: real UK and US lunch prices since 2000, and the money saved invested at real returns. |
| Coffee at home or buying | None found. | Yes: real UK and US coffee prices since 2000, bought and made at home, and the money saved invested at real returns. |
| Cost of waiting to invest | None found. Its investment calculator grows money at a rate you enter. | Yes: investing monthly from one year against starting later, with real returns and savings rates since 2000. |
| Lump sum or monthly | None found. Dollar cost averaging is covered in articles. | Yes: a sum invested all at once against fed in over 3 to 36 months, with real returns since 2000, and how often each came out ahead. |
| University or work | None found. Its student loan calculators work out repayments. | Yes: university or straight to work at 18, with real UK and US pay by age, tuition and student loan rules since 2000. |
| Pay off debt or invest | None found. Its early mortgage payoff calculator has no investing side. | Yes: paying a card or loan off first against investing, with real UK and US debt rates and stock returns since 2000. |
| High-yield or average savings | None found. Its savings calculator grows one account at an "Annual interest rate" you enter; the comparison with a high-yield account is in the text. | Yes: an average savings account against a high-yield one, with real UK rates since 2000 and US rates since 2009. |
| A cheaper car | A total car cost calculator for one car's monthly running costs, pre-filled with this year's averages. No second car and no investing. | Yes: the car you bought against a cheaper one with the difference invested, with real UK and US car prices, loan rates and returns since 2000. |
| Money spent on weed | None found. Its savings calculator grows an amount you enter. | Yes: what a light, regular or daily habit cost at real US legal prices since 2017 (UK from 2004), and what it would be worth invested. |
| Cash or a mortgage | None found. Its mortgage calculator works out payments from a "Home price" and "Down payment" you enter; no investing. | Yes: buying outright against a mortgage with the rest invested, deposits from 5% to 75%, with real UK and US rates and returns since 2000. |
| 15 or 30 year mortgage | Yes, side by side, with a "15-year interest rate (%)" you enter. It doesn't count investing the lower payment's difference. | Yes: a shorter against a longer mortgage with the lower payment's difference invested, with real Freddie Mac and Bank of England rates since 2000. |
| UK coverage | US only. NerdWallet's UK site closed in 2026. | UK and US. |
| Account needed | Not needed. | Not needed. |
| How it makes money | Some financial companies whose products appear on the site pay NerdWallet, for example referral fees. | No ads, no affiliate links, no paid version. |
You're planning ahead and want editor-set national defaults, today's cost of living in US cities, or links to shop for current rates. It also covers far more topics.
You want to know how a choice actually played out: in your place, from the month you made it, with the real prices, rents and rates since. It covers the UK as well as the US, and every figure names its source.
Checked on 23 September 2026 (25 September for investing timing, university and debt, and 27 September for high-yield savings, car costs, weed, cash or mortgage, and 15 or 30 years) against NerdWallet's own pages: NerdWallet rent vs buy calculator, How NerdWallet makes money. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at @ctrlaltdecide.